Soon millions of us will be asking the same question:
Back to Hierarchies OR Forward to Liberty and Justice for All?
"Everyone knows the right answer if they are just asked the right question."
Grab on. It's coming soon to your organization, radio station, website, etc.
Monday, December 20, 2010
Monday, December 13, 2010
Call for the Question
Obama wants us to believe that we must compromise with hierarchy–conservators, such as those who want tax breaks for the superrich. We don't agree with Obama about his necessity for compromise.
Here's a excerpt from our "Clueless Top" page of this website:
"In an effort to be fair, we often view top-of-the-hierarchy perspectives as personal opinions, and think we need to compromise, even if the top sees no need to compromise with us. We compromise with people who are building hierarchies, then wonder why our hierarchies continue. Compromising with people building hierarchies only builds more hierarchies."
Political and social movements of the United States or the world start with grass roots. It's now time for each of us who cares about any equality issue to unite with a common language. It's simple – we reframe our issue to create a united front that is huge in number and rich in diversity.
Imagine hundreds of millions of voices united and asking one question:
Are we a country of hierarchies?
or
Are we a country with Liberty and Justice for All?
Here's a excerpt from our "Clueless Top" page of this website:
"In an effort to be fair, we often view top-of-the-hierarchy perspectives as personal opinions, and think we need to compromise, even if the top sees no need to compromise with us. We compromise with people who are building hierarchies, then wonder why our hierarchies continue. Compromising with people building hierarchies only builds more hierarchies."
Political and social movements of the United States or the world start with grass roots. It's now time for each of us who cares about any equality issue to unite with a common language. It's simple – we reframe our issue to create a united front that is huge in number and rich in diversity.
Imagine hundreds of millions of voices united and asking one question:
Are we a country of hierarchies?
or
Are we a country with Liberty and Justice for All?
Friday, October 15, 2010
"Don't Ask, Don't Tell" Refuses to Die for Its Country
When we opened our newspapers today, we would liked to have read that our government is looking out for people throughout our hierarchies. Then we’d see:
The government suddenly ended the ban on “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,” as it would be disruptive and “irreparably harm the public interest in a strong and effective commitment to human rights and to all our citizens.”
But instead, we saw that every effort is being taken to take care of and please the top of our hierarchies. Thursday the Pentagon announced that it will comply with a court order to stop enforcing its "don't ask, don't tell" policy that bars gays from serving openly in the military, even as the Obama administration asked a federal judge to delay implementation of the ruling. The Obama administration has requested an emergency stay, saying:
Suddenly ending the ban would be disruptive and “irreparably harm the public interest in a strong and effective military. “
In 1978, our gay friend, Steve White, came home in a box from an Army base in Colorado, beaten to death by fellow servicemen, with no explanation to his family and no investigation. We’ve been waiting more than 30 years for the military to come around, and like millions of other Americans, we’re tired of waiting, especially when there’s many other men and women service people, like Steve, who live in harm’s way.
The government suddenly ended the ban on “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,” as it would be disruptive and “irreparably harm the public interest in a strong and effective commitment to human rights and to all our citizens.”
But instead, we saw that every effort is being taken to take care of and please the top of our hierarchies. Thursday the Pentagon announced that it will comply with a court order to stop enforcing its "don't ask, don't tell" policy that bars gays from serving openly in the military, even as the Obama administration asked a federal judge to delay implementation of the ruling. The Obama administration has requested an emergency stay, saying:
Suddenly ending the ban would be disruptive and “irreparably harm the public interest in a strong and effective military. “
In 1978, our gay friend, Steve White, came home in a box from an Army base in Colorado, beaten to death by fellow servicemen, with no explanation to his family and no investigation. We’ve been waiting more than 30 years for the military to come around, and like millions of other Americans, we’re tired of waiting, especially when there’s many other men and women service people, like Steve, who live in harm’s way.
Wednesday, September 29, 2010
Voters Hand Over Their Resources to the Top
Statistics released today by the US Census Bureau report that the top 20 percent of Americans received 49.4% of all income, compared with 3.4% made by the lower 20 percent. The ratio of 14.5 to 1 was an increase from 13.6 to 1 just two years ago in 2008. The income gap between the rich and the poor in the United States has grown to its largest margin ever.
And yet, many people in lower-income brackets still support Republican politicians who want to increase the divide even farther. There is a stark divide between Democrats and Republicans over whether to extend Bush-era tax cuts for the wealthy.
We hope that, as we increase our discussions of hierarchies in the United States, we will break out of our programming to listen to the people on top who are making decisions that benefit themselves. When statistics paint such a clear picture, we will not vote to channel our resources to the top.
And yet, many people in lower-income brackets still support Republican politicians who want to increase the divide even farther. There is a stark divide between Democrats and Republicans over whether to extend Bush-era tax cuts for the wealthy.
We hope that, as we increase our discussions of hierarchies in the United States, we will break out of our programming to listen to the people on top who are making decisions that benefit themselves. When statistics paint such a clear picture, we will not vote to channel our resources to the top.
Tuesday, August 31, 2010
Glenn Beck’s God has a Lot of Catching Up to Do
“This is the day we can start the hearts of Americans again, and it has nothing to do with politics and everything to do with God,” Glenn Beck told the crowd at the Restoring Honor rally in Washington D.C. on August 28. ”America today begins to turn back to God. For too long, this country has wandered in darkness."
If Mr. Beck wants to bring his God into a powerful position of bucking the trends of America, Sunday was probably none too early to start. In reality, Mr. Beck’s God probably should have been picking up steam a long time ago.
It’s no wonder Mr. Beck’s God is a little behind. Mr. Beck might tell his followers that they are man made in the image of God, but actually Mr. Beck’s God is made in the image of a man on top of a hierarchy – one that doles out judgments about rank and privilege based on religious affiliation, gender, sexual orientation, ethnicity, or whatever other criteria fits the conservative hierarchical agenda of the day.
Mr. Beck’s God is claimed to be the one and only God, and hence, God is on Mr. Beck’s side. We've had centuries of other hierarchy-conservators ("Hi-Cons") who have also claimed to be acting in the image of their one and only deity. Time after time, the deity du jour perfectly matches the conservative hierarchical agenda du jour – examples being segregation, indigenous genocide, subjugation of women, military aggression, or condemnation of same-sex partnerships.
In moving forward toward the U.S. founder's dream, we have continued to watch entrenched hierarchies crumble. Mr. Beck’s God is swimming upstream and may never be able to ever stem the tide.
While the followers of Mr. Beck's God have “wandered in darkness,” bounties for dead bodies or body parts of American Indians are no longer offered. Legalized slavery has been abolished. The age of legal consent for sexual relations was raised from seven years old. People of color can take an oath and testify in court. American Indian children are not forcibly sent hundreds of miles away from their families to white-run boarding schools. Men of color and women have the legal right to vote. Same-sex couples receive healthcare benefits in many workplaces.
Over the past fifty years, the civil rights movement, peace demonstrations, the women’s movement, farm workers’ boycotts, labor unions, and support for a healthy environment and family planning have made significant impacts on the United States. National organizations such as those promoting the rights of people with disabilities, American Indians, non-heterosexuals, and animals are making important inroads toward establishing equality and fairness.
In our wonderful land of the United States, Liberty and Justice for All is moving along at such a pace that Mr. Beck’s God will likely never be able to catch up.
If Mr. Beck wants to bring his God into a powerful position of bucking the trends of America, Sunday was probably none too early to start. In reality, Mr. Beck’s God probably should have been picking up steam a long time ago.
It’s no wonder Mr. Beck’s God is a little behind. Mr. Beck might tell his followers that they are man made in the image of God, but actually Mr. Beck’s God is made in the image of a man on top of a hierarchy – one that doles out judgments about rank and privilege based on religious affiliation, gender, sexual orientation, ethnicity, or whatever other criteria fits the conservative hierarchical agenda of the day.
Mr. Beck’s God is claimed to be the one and only God, and hence, God is on Mr. Beck’s side. We've had centuries of other hierarchy-conservators ("Hi-Cons") who have also claimed to be acting in the image of their one and only deity. Time after time, the deity du jour perfectly matches the conservative hierarchical agenda du jour – examples being segregation, indigenous genocide, subjugation of women, military aggression, or condemnation of same-sex partnerships.
In moving forward toward the U.S. founder's dream, we have continued to watch entrenched hierarchies crumble. Mr. Beck’s God is swimming upstream and may never be able to ever stem the tide.
While the followers of Mr. Beck's God have “wandered in darkness,” bounties for dead bodies or body parts of American Indians are no longer offered. Legalized slavery has been abolished. The age of legal consent for sexual relations was raised from seven years old. People of color can take an oath and testify in court. American Indian children are not forcibly sent hundreds of miles away from their families to white-run boarding schools. Men of color and women have the legal right to vote. Same-sex couples receive healthcare benefits in many workplaces.
Over the past fifty years, the civil rights movement, peace demonstrations, the women’s movement, farm workers’ boycotts, labor unions, and support for a healthy environment and family planning have made significant impacts on the United States. National organizations such as those promoting the rights of people with disabilities, American Indians, non-heterosexuals, and animals are making important inroads toward establishing equality and fairness.
In our wonderful land of the United States, Liberty and Justice for All is moving along at such a pace that Mr. Beck’s God will likely never be able to catch up.
Monday, August 23, 2010
Crosses Don't Represent Everyone
The Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled against 12-foot-high cross displays honoring fallen members of the Utah Highway Patrol (UHP). The court ruled that the 13 crosses, most on public land each bearing the name and badge number of deceased officers, sent a religious message to motorists on the state’s highways. According to the opinion: “We hold that these memorials have the impermissible effect of conveying to the reasonable observer the message that the State prefers or otherwise endorses a certain religion.”
We agree that crosses in public places indicate who is on top of our religious hierarchy.
Consistent and Predictable - The Top Represents Everyone
In any hierarchy, the attributes and roles of higher people are acceptable and appropriate for all. As Christianity is on top of our religious hierarchy in the United States:
The exclusive use of crosses in military cemeteries or at places where several people died assumes that a Christian symbol is appropriate to memorialize people of any religion.
If a symbol for a non-Christian religion is used, we assume the person honored followed that particular religion.
If a Jewish symbol were used, we would assume the person to be Jewish, even though we might not assume everyone honored by a cross to be Christian.
Attributes associated with lower people are considered appropriate for only that group of people. Characteristics associated with the lower group of people are often assumed to be inappropriate, even disgusting, for the higher group of people.
If a Christian were memorialized with a Muslim symbol, his or her family would likely protest, even though the same people might think that crosses are fine for all, believing a cross to be a universal symbol.
The Top Represents Everyone - more examples in other hierarchies
In our gender hierarchy, what is appropriate for males is also appropriate for females, but not vice-versa.
Female servers in fancy restaurants wear tuxedo-style uniforms even though it is unacceptable in those restaurants for male servers to wear evening dresses. It’s fine for a woman to wear overalls or business suit with a necktie a man would wear, but how about a man in lace and bows? How many baby boys wear pink?
In our schools, we teach the history of our dominant group telling our children this represents American History.
The “American History” traditionally taught to every student centers around the stories of wealthy able-bodied white males, the military, and wars. There are “special” separate classes for people who want to learn about anyone else — “African American History,” “History of American Indians,” or “Women’s History. ” If we take “Hispanic American History,” we don’t expect to learn “Asian American History.”
Role Reversals Help to Uncover Hierarchies
Role reversals are effective tools for uncovering elusive hierarchies that go undetected behind our assumptions about what's normal and natural. The higher group takes on the role of the lower, while the lower group plays the part usually played by the higher. We imagine the same scene played over again, however this time with roles switched.
In the state of Utah, a Buddist symbol was used to represent the places where state troopers had fallen. Since Buddism is on top of the religious hierarchy in the United States, it is consider to represent everyone.
We agree that crosses in public places indicate who is on top of our religious hierarchy.
Consistent and Predictable - The Top Represents Everyone
In any hierarchy, the attributes and roles of higher people are acceptable and appropriate for all. As Christianity is on top of our religious hierarchy in the United States:
The exclusive use of crosses in military cemeteries or at places where several people died assumes that a Christian symbol is appropriate to memorialize people of any religion.
If a symbol for a non-Christian religion is used, we assume the person honored followed that particular religion.
If a Jewish symbol were used, we would assume the person to be Jewish, even though we might not assume everyone honored by a cross to be Christian.
Attributes associated with lower people are considered appropriate for only that group of people. Characteristics associated with the lower group of people are often assumed to be inappropriate, even disgusting, for the higher group of people.
If a Christian were memorialized with a Muslim symbol, his or her family would likely protest, even though the same people might think that crosses are fine for all, believing a cross to be a universal symbol.
The Top Represents Everyone - more examples in other hierarchies
In our gender hierarchy, what is appropriate for males is also appropriate for females, but not vice-versa.
Female servers in fancy restaurants wear tuxedo-style uniforms even though it is unacceptable in those restaurants for male servers to wear evening dresses. It’s fine for a woman to wear overalls or business suit with a necktie a man would wear, but how about a man in lace and bows? How many baby boys wear pink?
In our schools, we teach the history of our dominant group telling our children this represents American History.
The “American History” traditionally taught to every student centers around the stories of wealthy able-bodied white males, the military, and wars. There are “special” separate classes for people who want to learn about anyone else — “African American History,” “History of American Indians,” or “Women’s History. ” If we take “Hispanic American History,” we don’t expect to learn “Asian American History.”
Role Reversals Help to Uncover Hierarchies
Role reversals are effective tools for uncovering elusive hierarchies that go undetected behind our assumptions about what's normal and natural. The higher group takes on the role of the lower, while the lower group plays the part usually played by the higher. We imagine the same scene played over again, however this time with roles switched.
In the state of Utah, a Buddist symbol was used to represent the places where state troopers had fallen. Since Buddism is on top of the religious hierarchy in the United States, it is consider to represent everyone.
Wednesday, August 4, 2010
Set Up the Top
Our friend Anne forwarded us an email that provides an opportunity to use the technique, "Set Them Up," from the Take Action - Clueless Top webpage. Here's the email Anne received:
Hi Anne,
I send a Facebook request to all twins so I am sending you one. How is your brother Alan? If you don't want to accept my request, I will understand since I don't agree with your lifestyle (that is my opinion but wouldn't let that stop me from being your friend). :) Is Alan on Facebook? If so, I would like to send him a friend request also. I sure have enjoyed being a twin for you always have a best friend. Love your profile photo!
Becky
We respond to Becky's comment about lesbians, by using her rhetoric at face value, and then substituting a scenario based on what it would look like if Becky were not supporting a sexual orientation hierarchy:
Hi Becky,
Thank you for your invitation. Yes, it is fun being a twin. It appears from your email that it is important to you that we write about whether or not we agree with each other's lifestyles. I would like to honor your criteria. It's been 40 years since we went to high school together, but I don't know anything about you now. If you send me some information about your lifestyle, I'll be glad to comment. Thanks. :)
Anne
Hi Anne,
I send a Facebook request to all twins so I am sending you one. How is your brother Alan? If you don't want to accept my request, I will understand since I don't agree with your lifestyle (that is my opinion but wouldn't let that stop me from being your friend). :) Is Alan on Facebook? If so, I would like to send him a friend request also. I sure have enjoyed being a twin for you always have a best friend. Love your profile photo!
Becky
We respond to Becky's comment about lesbians, by using her rhetoric at face value, and then substituting a scenario based on what it would look like if Becky were not supporting a sexual orientation hierarchy:
Hi Becky,
Thank you for your invitation. Yes, it is fun being a twin. It appears from your email that it is important to you that we write about whether or not we agree with each other's lifestyles. I would like to honor your criteria. It's been 40 years since we went to high school together, but I don't know anything about you now. If you send me some information about your lifestyle, I'll be glad to comment. Thanks. :)
Anne
Friday, July 16, 2010
Look Out not Up, Obama!
When Barack Obama promised that he understood the need for change, many of us believed him. We saw his experience in lower groups of hierarchies – single mom, African American of mixed race, non-wealthy childhood – and concluded that he gets it that we need a monumental move away from hierarchies that favor those at the top.
If George W. Bush had tried the same campaign message, his promises would not have been credible because he has lived his life clueless on top of every major hierarchy in the United States.
It’s regrettable that Obama has chosen to surround himself with peers in his own higher groups, for example, people who are currently wealthy and associated with elite private schools. Obama appears to have isolated himself from the wisdom, knowledge, and perspectives that only come from experiences and associations with lower groups.
We expected and were promised a fresh outlook from Obama which he can't produce as long as his line of sight is up toward the top..
We hope that Obama will soon begin to turn his head and look out, not up. Only then will Obama become the national and global leader that the world wants and needs.
"You have billions of us who are rooting for you."
–Paul McCartney to Obama, June, 2010
If George W. Bush had tried the same campaign message, his promises would not have been credible because he has lived his life clueless on top of every major hierarchy in the United States.
It’s regrettable that Obama has chosen to surround himself with peers in his own higher groups, for example, people who are currently wealthy and associated with elite private schools. Obama appears to have isolated himself from the wisdom, knowledge, and perspectives that only come from experiences and associations with lower groups.
We expected and were promised a fresh outlook from Obama which he can't produce as long as his line of sight is up toward the top..
We hope that Obama will soon begin to turn his head and look out, not up. Only then will Obama become the national and global leader that the world wants and needs.
"You have billions of us who are rooting for you."
–Paul McCartney to Obama, June, 2010
We Can't Wait
We can’t wait for people at the top to come around before we push for change.
When Senator Robert Byrd died recently at 92, he was remembered as a man who supported civil rights in his later years, but as a younger man made statements such as: “The Klan is needed today as never before, and I am anxious to see its rebirth here in West Virginia,” and “Men are not created equal today, and they were not created equal in 1776.”
One of our most famous pro-segregation leaders, Alabama Governor George Wallace, made national headlines when he attempted to block African Americans from enrolling in the University of Alabama. Then decades later, in 1979, Wallace said of his stand in the schoolhouse door: "I was wrong. Those days are over and they ought to be over."
What if the leaders of the civil rights movement had waited until Robert Byrd or George Wallace embraced integration? They would have been wasting precious time, energy, and resources that they needed for making sweeping changes.
The lessons of Byrd and Wallace are applicable today as we work to weaken other hierarchies. The top may come around eventually, but we can’t wait for them or expect them to change now.
When Senator Robert Byrd died recently at 92, he was remembered as a man who supported civil rights in his later years, but as a younger man made statements such as: “The Klan is needed today as never before, and I am anxious to see its rebirth here in West Virginia,” and “Men are not created equal today, and they were not created equal in 1776.”
One of our most famous pro-segregation leaders, Alabama Governor George Wallace, made national headlines when he attempted to block African Americans from enrolling in the University of Alabama. Then decades later, in 1979, Wallace said of his stand in the schoolhouse door: "I was wrong. Those days are over and they ought to be over."
What if the leaders of the civil rights movement had waited until Robert Byrd or George Wallace embraced integration? They would have been wasting precious time, energy, and resources that they needed for making sweeping changes.
The lessons of Byrd and Wallace are applicable today as we work to weaken other hierarchies. The top may come around eventually, but we can’t wait for them or expect them to change now.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)